Arthur completes the current Herbalist challenge and comes across Pearson and Sadie having a heated argument. Sadie is discontent with having to stay in camp all day and do nothing but cook, stating that when her husband was alive, they shared the chores around their ranch. Arthur decides to take her into Rhodes to buy more supplies for Pearson. Before they leave, Pearson gives Arthur a letter to post for him. On their way, Sadie cheekily reads Pearson's letter (which is for his aunt Cathy) while mockingly imitating him, which amuses Arthur. Sadie then notices a Tacitus Kilgore. Arthur states it's an alias for mail to be sent to the gang. Upon arriving, Sadie wants to rob the store but Arthur tells her they are not meant to cause any trouble. Sadie enters the store while Arthur goes to the post office to mail Pearson's letter. When returning to the wagon, Sadie is seen with new attire and bickering at the store clerk, who is loading boxes into the back of the wagon. As they are heading back to the camp, Sadie expresses her sadness of how both her home and possessions were destroyed and how she used to enjoy playing the harmonica. Arthur apologizes for what she went through and offers to find a new harmonica for her. Sadie just tells him to treat her like everyone else and firmly declares that no one will ever ruin her life again. Suddenly, two members of the Lemoyne Raiders approach them and order them to stop in an attempt to rob them. Sadie refuses, shoots one of them and runs down another with the wagon, resulting in more members attacking. After Arthur and Sadie fight them off, they drive the wagon back into camp, and Arthur decides to not tell Dutch about their encounter. Upon arriving, they help Pearson unload the supplies from the wagon. Sadie thanks Arthur for taking her out and Arthur replies that he would be happy to ride with her again. Arthur then gives her the harmonica and sees Karen and Susan get into it again. Micah thanks Arthur for saving his life and talks to Sean on guard duty. Arthur then asks Sadie to remind him to bring more bullets when they head out together. Uncle attempts to charm Susan while Arthur plays dominoes with Tilly who reveals she lost her necklace while fleeing Blackwater, Hosea then asks Arthur to poke around the two families from before while Micah gloats about bringing in money, Arthur tells Sadie he didn't notify Dutch of the diversion on the way back to camp while Sadie states she can and will fight at any time. Charless then explains why he is the way he is with Arthur telling him he's the best man he knows. Arthur then plays five finger fillet with Micah and makes progress with the next Herbalist challenge and listen Lenny tell a story involving a watch he obtained from his father only to lose it while escaping Blackwater, luckily Arthur gives him one of the watches he already had and watches Micah and Javier bond while drunk.