Arthur finishes the Survivalist challenge and buys the equipment from the other challenges at the Trapper before killing O'Driscolls. After arriving in camp, Arthur sees Micah rile up Hosea while Sean sings a song. Arthur catches two guys trying to break open a safe and relieves them of it before confronting Gwyn Hughes. The undertaker tells Arthur that he does not have any money on him but knows of a brooch he can use to pay back the money instead. Hughes uncomfortably reveals that it is from Mrs. Claypole, a woman buried in the cemetery, and asks Arthur to divert people away from the graveyard so that he can exhume the brooch without being spotted. Eventually, Gwyn manages to obtain the jewelry and gives it to Arthur, who tells him that it satisfies his debt. Arthur meets Dutch and Bill at the Sheriff's Office where Dutch tells him that Sheriff Gray has made them temporary deputies, so that they can help Archibald shut down a moonshine distillery. Arthur and Archibald mount a wagon, while Dutch and Bill ride behind them. Archibald regales Arthur with the Rhodes history, as well as the Gray-Braithwaite feud. Along the way, they will come across the dead body of a Lemoyne state legislator named Fredrick Mitchell, who was killed by the Lemoyne Raiders. The four men finally arrive at the swamp where the moonshiners are working, and they split up. Arthur and Bill take one side and knock out the moonshiners over there, while Dutch and Archibald attack the other side. They then pick up the moonshiners, as well as the moonshine itself, and deposit them in the wagon. Archibald then tells Arthur and Bill to blow up the moonshiners' distillery with dynamite. Arthur does so, but the buyers, who are a group of Lemoyne Raiders, hear the commotion from their camp nearby. A gunfight ensues, and Arthur and Bill fight them off. The pair then return to the carriage, where they see that Archibald has not yet destroyed the moonshine. He explains that it is "traditional" for the law to drink the moonshine as reward for dealing with the criminals, and offers most of it to the gang. Dutch accepts, and Bill drives the wagon back to camp while Archibald escorts the captured moonshiners away. As Arthur and Dutch ride off together, Dutch says that with the help of Hosea, he reckons that they will be able to play both the Grays and the Braithwaites from both sides. Arthur teases Dutch on how he is talking like "the young Dutch", and Dutch challenges him to a race back to camp which results in Arthur being victorious leading Dutch to state he considers Arthur more than a son to him before leaving. Bill tells Arthur that Hosea's working on a plan for the moonshine and tells Strauss he's got money for the box while Dutch encourages the gang to bring in money along with spotting Micah attempt to charm Abigail. Dutch tells Arthur there hiding in plain sight and to have faith as Bill attempts to bond with Kieran while Sean insults Micah. Lenny then expresses confusion about keeping up with all the folks coming after them.