సుప్రీంకోర్టుకు 14 ప్రశ్నలు అడిగిన ప్రెసిడెంట్ ముర్ము | Executive Vs Judiciary | Vishnu IAS Academy

President Droupadi Murmu Questions Supreme Court’s Timeline on State Bills | Article 143 Explained President Droupadi Murmu has invoked Article 143(1) of the Constitution to refer 14 crucial questions to the Supreme Court regarding its recent ruling on the timeframe for gubernatorial assent to state bills. She raised concerns over whether the Court can fix timelines when the Constitution—especially Articles 200 and 201—does not specify any. President Murmu Questions 1. What are the constitutional options before a Governor when a Bill is presented to him under Article 200 of the Constitution of India? 2. Is the Governor bound by the aid & advice tendered by the Council of Ministers while exercising all the options available with him when a Bill is presented before him under Article 200 of the Constitution of India? 3. Is the exercise of constitutional discretion by the Governor under Article 200 of the Constitution of India justiciable? 4. Is Article 361 of the Constitution of India an absolute bar to the judicial review in relation to the actions of a Governor under Article 200 of the Constitution of India? 5. In the absence of a constitutionally prescribed time limit, and the manner of exercise of powers by the Governor, can timelines be imposed and the manner of exercise be prescribed through judicial orders for the exercise of all powers under Article 200 of the Constitution of India by the Governor? 6. Is the exercise of constitutional discretion by the President under Article 201 of the Constitution of India justiciable? 7. In the absence of a constitutionally prescribed timeline and the manner of exercise of powers by the President, can timelines be imposed and the manner of exercise be prescribed through judicial orders for the exercise of discretion by the President under Article 201 of the Constitution of India? 8. In light of the constitutional scheme governing the powers of the President, is the President required to seek advice of the Supreme Court by way of a reference under Article 143 of the Constitution of India and take the opinion of the Supreme Court when the Governor reserves a Bill for the President's assent or otherwise? 9. Are the decisions of the Governor and the President under Article 200 and Article 201 of the Constitution of India, respectively, justiciable at a stage anterior into the law coming into force? Is it permissible for the Courts to undertake judicial adjudication over the contents of a Bill, in any manner, before it becomes law? 10. Can the exercise of constitutional powers and the orders of/by the President / Governor be substituted in any manner under Article 142 of the Constitution of India? 11. Is a law made by the State legislature a law in force without the assent of the Governor granted under Article 200 of the Constitution of India? 12. In view of the proviso to Article 145(3) of the Constitution of India, is it not mandatory for any bench of this Hon'ble Court to first decide as to whether the question involved in the proceedings before it is of such a nature which involves substantial questions of law as to the interpretation of constitution and to refer it to a bench of minimum five Judges? 13. Does the Constitution bar any other jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to resolve disputes between the Union Government and the State Governments except by way of a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution of India? 🔔 Don’t forget to like, share & subscribe for daily current affairs and UPSC insights! Follow us on This is the Social Media channels of Vishnu IAS for UPSC CSE preparation. We are one of the fastest growing institutes in the country for UPSC CSE. Please do Follow and Subscribe: Instagram:   / vishnuias_official   Facebook:   / vishnuiasacademy   Youtube :    / @tgpscappscupscvishnuias   Youtube :    / @vishnuiasacademy   Telegram: https://t.me/vishnuiaschannel Whatsapp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaBi... Telegram for Exclusive TSPSC/APPSC: https://t.me/targetTSPSCAPPSCvishnuias Full Course Details: APPSC: https://vishnuias.com/prelims-cum-mains/ TSPSC: https://vishnuias.com/tspsc/ #president #supremecourt #presidentvssupremecourt #droupadimurmu #executive #judiciary #presidentmurmu #indianconstitution #currentaffairs2025 #latestnews #vishnuiasacademy #vishnuias