Andrew appears in more than just 3 rooms; that was a commentary mistake. He only appears in Water Prison and in one room near the end of the game. If you want to take the sword out of Andrew, then the best ghost to pin would be Eric Walsh (the same ghost that we found pinned in Building World). Next: • Silent Hill 4: The Room 100% - #11 - Build... Previous: • Silent Hill 4: The Room 100% - #9.5 - Fore... Full playlist: • Silent Hill 4: The Room 100% Walkthrough A 100% playthrough/walkthrough of Silent Hill 4: The Room. All unlockables, all memos, and all 10 stars. All because I love this game.