Time to REPLACE the Indian Constitution? with Mrunal Patel, Sarmad Mehraj & Pratik Nayak
Time to REPLACE the Indian Constitution? Big Polity Debate with Mrunal Patel, Sarmad Mehraj & Pratik Nayak On 26 November – Constitution Day 2025 – we bring you the most intense and enlightening debate ever seen on Indian YouTube! Three powerhouse educators go head-to-head: • Mrunal Patel Sir (Economy Expert) • Pratik Nayak Sir (History Expert) • Sarmad Meheraj Sir (Polity & Governance Expert) The big question: Does 21st-century India need a completely NEW Constitution, or do we just need to implement the existing one in letter and spirit? In this 60+ minute marathon debate, we covered almost every burning issue: • Is the Preamble still perfect or was adding “Secular & Socialist” a mistake? • Emergency provisions – copied from Weimar or necessary evil? • Should Fundamental Rights be ABSOLUTE or do reasonable restrictions make sense? • Freedom of Speech vs Public Order – movie bans, hate speech & creative freedom • Liquor ban, federalism & double standards in DPSP implementation • Judicial overreach or political class failure? • Election Commission independence & appointment controversy • Rajya Sabha domicile rule removal – betrayal of federalism? • Is India quasi-federal or can we become a true federation? • Britain-style unwritten constitution – should India adopt it? Perfect for UPSC CSE 2026/27, State PCS, CLAT, Judiciary & all competitive exams. This single video will clear decades of confusion on Indian Polity. If you are serious about your exam, watch till the end, take notes & thank us later! Like, Share & Subscribe + Hit the bell icon. Timestamps 00:00 – Opening animation + disclaimer 06:46 – Mrunal Sir Host welcome + आज संविधान दिवस है + दोनों सर का introduction 07:11 – Sarmad Sir Opening Argument (Dr. Ambedkar quote + “Most beautiful Constitution”) 08:15 – Pratik Sir Opening – Bag of Borrowings + Preamble में Secular-Socialist जोड़ना 10:35 – Sarmad Sir Counter – Living Document + Nehru & Ambedkar on amendments 14:02 – Emergency Provisions Debate (Weimar, 1935 Act, 1975 misuse) 17:38 – Fundamental Rights – Absolute vs Reasonable Restrictions 18:03 – Freedom of Speech – “Fire in theatre” example + movie bans + hate speech 26:30 – What is Absolute Fundamental Rights and What is not? 29:00 – Right to Life - Liquor Ban, Federalism & DPSP hypocrisy (Bihar-Gujarat-Kerala examples) 38:58 – Judicial Creativity vs Overreach + Unenumerated rights (Privacy, Climate Change) 48:10 – Election Commission independence & appointment controversy 53:44 – Rajya Sabha domicile rule removal (2003 amendment) 1:00:27 – Federalism – Quasi-Federal nature + US Senate comparison + Delimitation 2026 1:08:10 – Closing Arguments – Britain-style unwritten constitution? Majoritarianism danger Unacademy Offering Your UPSC preparation deserves the best guidance — and now it’s finally affordable! Get India’s Top Educators, complete syllabus coverage, GS + CSAT, test series, mains evaluation & doubt-solving — all at just ₹19,999. Join Now: https://unacademy.com/goal/upsc-civil... If you’re starting UPSC prep… this is the perfect time. Offer Ends Tonight! Gear up for the UPSC CSE Interview Program: The Last Mile 2025. If you’ve cleared Mains, this is your moment—register now: https://unacademy.com/content/upsc/th... Educator Details 👨🏫 Dr. Mrunal Patel ▶ Profile: https://unacademy.com/@mrunal.org 👨🏫 Sarmad Mehraj ▶ Profile: https://unacademy.com/@syed.sarmad37/ 👨🏫 Pratik Nayak ▶ Profile: https://unacademy.com/@nayakpratik Follow Us 👉 Telegram: https://t.me/unstoppablesupsc 👉 Instagram: / unacademyupscias Hashtags #ConstitutionDay #ConstitutionDay2025 #IndianConstitution #DrAmbedkar #RewriteConstitution #BagOfBorrowings #FundamentalRights #EmergencyProvisions #Federalism #JudicialOverreach #ElectionCommission #RajyaSabha #UPSC2026 #UPSC2027 #UPSCPolity #PolityForUPSC #CLAT2026 #judiciaryexams #UnacademyUPSC SEO Tags Constitution Day, Constitution Day 2025, Samvidhan Divas, Indian Constitution Debate, New Constitution India, Rewrite Indian Constitution, Dr BR Ambedkar, Bag of Borrowings, Preamble of India, Secular Socialist Debate, Emergency in Indian Constitution, Fundamental Rights, Reasonable Restrictions, Freedom of Speech India, Article 19, Article 21, Judicial Overreach, Judicial Activism, Election Commission India, ECI Independence, Rajya Sabha Domicile, Federalism in India, Quasi Federal, Basic Structure Doctrine, Kesavananda Bharati, DPSP vs Fundamental Rights, Uniform Civil Code, Article 356, Polity UPSC, Indian Polity for UPSC, UPSC CSE 2026, UPSC Mains Polity, Prateek Nayak Polity, Sarbajit Sir, Lets Crack It UPSC, UPSC Motivation, UPSC Polity in English, Constitution Day Special, Ambedkar Jayanti, Indian Polity Lectures, CLAT Polity, Judiciary Exam Polity, State PCS Polity, PSIR Optional UPSC