Prove Me Wrong: This Is The Greatest Nintendo Game Of All Time | Challenge My GOAT

Grab your controllers and power up! On this episode of Challenge My GOAT, Polygon’s Editor-at-Large Giovanni Colantonio takes aim with Metroid Prime, while Game Informer’s Executive Editor Brian Shea draws his Master Sword for The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, as they battle it out for the title of greatest Nintendo game of all time! Will victory go to Samus Aran’s lonely adventure through alien worlds, or to Link’s timeless quest that helped to define 3D gaming itself? First-person isolation or open-world inspiration? Beam Cannon or Fairy Bow? You decide, on this episode of Challenge My GOAT! 0:00 Welcome – Stakes of the GOAT call 1:25 Gio crowns Metroid Prime (opening case) 6:13 Shea counters + the remaster lens 8:09 Ocarina of Time enters the arena 12:10 Franchise context: sequels, timelines, legacies 16:18 Story vs gameplay vs music 21:15 Prime’s scan lore & environmental storytelling 27:31 Closing arguments & takeaways Subscribe | Enable ALL push notifications 🔔    / @screenrant   Follow Screen Rant: TikTok:   / screenrant   Twitter:   / screenrant   Facebook:   / screenrant   LinkedIn:   / screen-rant   Official Screen Rant Website: http://screenrant.com/ Host: Liam Crowley https://screenrant.com/author/liam-cr... https://www.instagram.com/liamtcrowle...   / liam-crowley-758b0b180   Author: Giovanni Colantonio https://www.polygon.com/author/giovan...   / giovanni-colantonio-20540334   https://x.com/marioprim Challenger: Brian Shea https://www.instagram.com/brianpshea/... Editor and Producer: John Aljets For copyright matters please contact us at: [email protected] #nintendo #zelda #metroidprime #ocarinaoftime #gaming #challengemygoat #screenrant #videogames